jueves, 20 de noviembre de 2014

PINK FLOYD'S ANOTHER BRICK IN THE WALL




In the very time that I heard about the central topic of 1984 in class, a specific video came to my mind: Pink Floyd's Another Brick In The Wall which has always caught my attention in the sense that it shows how controlled we are as society since a long time ago. For me, the similarity between the story and the song is quite obvious since the message is the same: oppression.


There is little doubt about 1984's central topic: totalitarianism and oppression. 1984 shows a dystopian or negative utopian world in which people's life is controlled by an omniscient figure, in this case the Party or the Big Brother. This Party wants to control not only every part of the society of that time in the sense that they decide what you can and cannot do but also they constantly fill in people's mind with the party´s thought. Its main character is called Winston Smith who lives in this controlled society, where individuality and freedom do not exist at all.


Almost 40 years later, this negative thinking about society had not changed that much. The song " Another Brick In The Wall" is part of the Pink Floyd's album called "The Wall" in which different “Pink's stories” are told. In “Another Brick In The Wall” Pink wants to write poetry but that is something impossible for that time so he is ridiculed by his teacher. The teacher represents the society and the education of that time which was turning children into mindless drones. This idea is shown very literally in Pink Floyd's video in which children walk and pass through a brick wall and when they come out, they are not individuals anymore but a crowd of equal children or just more bricks in the wall.

Every single creation represents something, a good or bad experience within the authors' lives no matter if it is a story or a song. 
In the former case, it is of great importance knowing that George Orwell was educated in boarding schools in which he never fitted in. Actually, he felt oppressed by the control that the schools exercised over him and the other students’ lives.However, he decided to work for the British Imperial Policeman where he was also controlled. In the second case, the song's protagonist, Pink, represents the vocalist Roger Waters' alter-ego since Waters, part of a Britain hit by the Second World War, was educated under a "thought control" and "sarcastic" education system as the song says and where teachers are those who represent oppression.



The relation between the story and the song is the message and the relation between Orwell and Waters is that both were oppressive educated. This early oppression had a great impact on their lives, of course on their creations and on society. If we think about it, everything is connected since education is the basis of society and people’s development and the other way around as well.


Even though there are more than one interpretation of “Another Brick In The Wall”, in my opinion there is just one: 

                                         We don't need no education.
                                         We don't need no thought control.
                                         No dark sarcasm in the classroom.
                                         Teacher leave them kids alone


We do not need an oppressed education which controls what to think, what to do and where someone who wants to write poetry such as Pink in the song or Winston in 1984 be punished. We do need education, but an education that teaches us to think as individuals instead of a crowd!





Sources
-http://www.thewallanalysis.com/main/another-brick1.html
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqPwffptR-E

2 comentarios:

  1. I really like the song but I had not made the conection with the novels until now that you posted it. It makes sense if we see the major topic of both novels 1984 and V for Vendetta is that totalitarism wants to "fool" people and make them feel comfortable in the society that they create and make people believe that is is indeed necessary to be opressed by totalitarian governments.
    A wall works as a perfect imagery for this concepts like uniformization, because everyone must act and think the same, no one can disrupt the order. Also a wall is made of concrete, something that is not alive, something that can not think. a wall is a human invention made to fulfil the human's own purpose, a wall is made to fulfill someone elses purpose, so imagine the impact of comparing each one of us as a brick in the wall, in the sense that we are useful to fulfill some one elses (the totalitarian government) purposes.
    What if education is seem as a weapon to uniform everyone? everyone must learn the same things and behave the similarly. Now, if we consider that "history is writen by the victors" aren't we in a way doing the same thing that happens in 1984 when the Ministries edit the facts of the past? Aren's we doing the same thing nowadays by making kids learn only ONE version of history at school?

    ResponderEliminar
  2. 1984 presents a reality which is not that different than ours. Politicians tell us “what are our needs” and promise us that if we vote for them, our “needs” will be pleased. In the case of 1984, that society needs protection of the war and food, to name a few but in exchange of complete obedience and loyalty to Big Brother and the Party. The way that authorities harass the society, the way in which the use propaganda to make them think that oppression is right and freedom is bad and the way that the spread edited news, give Big Brother and the Party the total control of people´s mind and loyalty. With that control, they make people become another brick in the wall.

    ResponderEliminar